Thompson Center Encore Classifieds
Find your Encore Barrels here!

Home » General Conversation » Gun Talk » questions about barrel length
questions about barrel length [message #33610] Mon, 20 October 2014 20:47 Go to next message
765bowhunter is currently offline  765bowhunter
Messages: 69
Registered: October 2012
Location: indiana
Novice Contributor
Hello everyone, I am wanting to build a small rifle for my son to hunt with soon, I want to keep it light weight, light recoil, and compact. I was thinking about buying a rifle barrel and having it cut down to about 18 inches or so..... but now I'm thinking about getting a pistol barrel and permanently attaching a muzzle brake. I know a rifle barrel must be 16+ inches, so if I take a pro hunter pistol barrel 15 inches, add a brake +2 inches or so, I will definitely be over the 16 inch minimum. My question is, can I take a designated pistol barrel and turn it into a rifle barrel? Doing it this way will definitely be cheaper then a rifle barrel cut, recrowned, and a brake added, but I don't want walk on any fine lines with the law.
Re: questions about barrel length [message #33611 is a reply to message #33610] Mon, 20 October 2014 21:45 Go to previous messageGo to next message
jamesgammel is currently offline  jamesgammel
Messages: 1708
Registered: August 2012
Location: Lovell, Wyoming
Top Contributor
You could take an 18 and have an integral M-B cut into it. A 15 would only need a 1 1/4 extension added which could be the Muzzle Brake and be legal, just must be PERMANANTLY affixed. T/C's Custom shop in instructions for ordering barrels was ADD 1 1/8th inch to an existing barrel to figure finished length. Your 15 would end up at 16 1/8th under that general rule.That 1/8th is enuff unless you intend to have your kid out hunting in -40* weather. Cutting,re-crown is usually done when a brake is added anyway so your cost analysis doesn't fly. It would be done with a pistol barrel unless the crown was already great. 18+ a brake is 19 1/8th with a muzzle-tamer added. Just remember which ever way you go, don't figure you'll get any velocity gain with that additional 1 1/8", it adds NOTHING for velocity. And an 18 with an integral LOSES velocity, you've effectively got an 18- 1 1/8 barrel or 16 15/16's worth of rifling.
Jim

[Updated on: Mon, 20 October 2014 21:46]

Report message to a moderator

Re: questions about barrel length [message #33615 is a reply to message #33611] Tue, 21 October 2014 07:37 Go to previous messageGo to next message
rchatting is currently offline  rchatting
Messages: 499
Registered: August 2011
Location: Middle Georgia
Forum Regular

^^^yeah, what he said^^^

One other thing, a muzzle tamer is going to make it much louder to the shooter. Which shortening a barrel generally increases noise but anything that makes the gas go up or back instead of away from the shooter is going to need ear plugs for sure. A louder report also gives the "impression" of more recoil to the shooter. Go with a lesser caliber to keep recoil down and ditch the tamer idea. Will save you $$ also.
Re: questions about barrel length [message #33617 is a reply to message #33615] Tue, 21 October 2014 08:05 Go to previous messageGo to next message
jamesgammel is currently offline  jamesgammel
Messages: 1708
Registered: August 2012
Location: Lovell, Wyoming
Top Contributor
David White will add to barrel length to almost anything you could want. Either way, as merely an extension or extension and brake. He and Bellm (who does integral only) include putting a 11* target crown at the end of the rifled portion. Most of the T/C barrels I have seen for some time merely have a recessed crown. Your local gunsmith may or may not care about the crown. Bellm can make a brake as short as an inch, fewer but larger exit holes. White's extensions with brake add zero rifling, Bellms eats rifling.
I believe ^^^mention about "impression" is due to the "startle effect". Louder report increases that startle effect and can create rise for "flinching", body's natural reaction to startle whether by light or sound. On the range that can build up as the session goes on. In the field, assuming one shot, one kill, It will yield negligible effect. The repeated report at the range makes it critically important for hearing protection, with a brake, much more so. Since White will add an extension without a brake to yield the length necessary to change a pistol to rifle barrel, you may want to ditch the brake consideration. You'll have to weigh your son's weight, size, the weight of the total package etc to decide which chambering to go with, and it's intended target species. Lighter weight bullets does help with getting lesser recoil. It's a balancing act to make those decisions.
Jim
Re: questions about barrel length [message #33618 is a reply to message #33615] Tue, 21 October 2014 08:13 Go to previous messageGo to next message
765bowhunter is currently offline  765bowhunter
Messages: 69
Registered: October 2012
Location: indiana
Novice Contributor
Ok, thank you for your quick responses, I'm thinking a rifle barrel cut down will be the way to go.
Re: questions about barrel length [message #33619 is a reply to message #33618] Tue, 21 October 2014 08:28 Go to previous messageGo to next message
jamesgammel is currently offline  jamesgammel
Messages: 1708
Registered: August 2012
Location: Lovell, Wyoming
Top Contributor
I assume then that you'll need to purchase a new barrel. Once you decide caliber, I highly suggest checking Ed's list to see if he has a barrel that will be suitable. Considering the price of even a used barrel plus the shortening, you may save $$ thru ed's and get a much higher quality shooter for the same or less outlay. His barrels come in various lengths, and calibers and made by MGM. He can "order one" if asked and have it delivered right to you and save you a ton of $$, for maybe a 3 month wait.
Call, don't email, even if he already lists what you want.
Jim
Re: questions about barrel length [message #33625 is a reply to message #33619] Tue, 21 October 2014 11:37 Go to previous messageGo to next message
765bowhunter is currently offline  765bowhunter
Messages: 69
Registered: October 2012
Location: indiana
Novice Contributor
I don't plan on starting this until next spring or summer when I find out for sure if they will make rifles legal to deer hunt with here in Indiana. If they do make them legal for next year I was planning on buying a 7mm08 barrel for myself anyway, so was just going to let him try mine and go from there. I got my son one of the hot shot 22lr and it fits him perfectly, that's why I'm assuming it needs to be around 18 inches.
Re: questions about barrel length [message #33627 is a reply to message #33625] Tue, 21 October 2014 14:54 Go to previous messageGo to next message
rchatting is currently offline  rchatting
Messages: 499
Registered: August 2011
Location: Middle Georgia
Forum Regular
Is Indiana one of those states that allows the pistol caliber in a rifle? If so, why not get a .357max from Bellm? If it fits the criteria. Can shoot .357 mag or max out of it. THen you can get other barrels in the future if you like.
Re: questions about barrel length [message #33629 is a reply to message #33627] Tue, 21 October 2014 15:48 Go to previous message
765bowhunter is currently offline  765bowhunter
Messages: 69
Registered: October 2012
Location: indiana
Novice Contributor
Yea its one of those states lol but its looking like its gonna change next year. If they don't change the laws then I will start looking into pistol cartridges like 357 max or maybe even 44 mag, I'm just hoping for a rifle cartridge like 243 oar 7mm08
Previous Topic: 357 max
Next Topic: C-MORE red-dot sight
Goto Forum:
  


Current Time: Wed May 15 02:36:37 EDT 2024